Explore Legal.io

For Clients
Legal.io company logo
Hire Talent
Find the best fit for any legal role
For Members
Jobs
The best legal jobs, updated daily
Salaries
Benchmark compensation for any legal role
Learn
Learn and grow with our community
Events
Connect with peers at exclusive events
Apps
Tools to streamline legal work
Advertise on Legal.io
Post a job for free
Reach more qualified applicants quickly
Advertise with Us
Reach a targeted audience

For Clients

Hire Talent
Legal.io company logo
Solutions
Find the best fit for any legal role
New Hire
Get highly qualified candidates in days
Popular Roles
Data & Tools
Budget Calculator
Plan and manage your legal budget
Salary Insights
Compensation data for legal roles
Vendor Directory
The ultimate list of legal tech tools

Ross Antitrust Claims Over Westlaw Dismissed

Ross Intelligence failed to convince a federal judge that Thomson Reuters is forcing people to buy its Westlaw search tools in exchange for access to its caselaw database.

Ross Antitrust Claims Over Westlaw Dismissed
  • A federal judge dismissed the antitrust case brought by ROSS Intelligence against Thomson Reuters, citing insufficient evidence.

  • ROSS had accused Thomson Reuters of monopolizing legal research by unlawfully tying its search tool to its public law database.

  • A separate AI copyright case Thomson Reuters brought against ROSS is still pending.

A federal judge dismissed antitrust claims filed against Thomson Reuters after finding that the plaintiff, former legal research startup ROSS Intelligence failed to provide sufficient evidence to back its case, according to LawNext.com.

Details of the Antitrust Case

  • ROSS claimed that Thomson Reuters violated federal antitrust law by unlawfully tying its search tool to its public law database in order to maintain its dominance in the overall market for legal search platforms.

  • ROSS’s insisted that Westlaw caselaw database is a standalone product that many consumers want to buy, but that Thomson Reuters will sell it only when it is packaged with Westlaw’s search tools, which ROSS alleged was a separate product.

  • In 2022, Judge Leonard P. Stark, who previously presided over the case, dismissed a portion of ROSS’s antitrust claims, but he allowed the tying claim to move forward

  • However, Third U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals Judge Stephanos Bibas, sitting by designation in the U.S. District Court in Delaware, granted Thomson Reuters’s motion for summary judgment on the tying claim, concluding that ROSS had failed to back up its allegations with sufficient evidence.

AI Copyright Case Still Ongoing

Judge Bibas’s ruling brings an end to ROSS’s counterclaims against Thomson Reuters in an ongoing litigation between the two parties.

  • An AI copyright suit filed by Thomson Reuters against ROSS is still pending.

  • Thomson Reuters alleges that ROSS unlawfully used Westlaw legal texts to train its own AI-powered legal research tool. 

  • The AI copyright case was scheduled to go to trial in August 2024, but Judge Bibas postponed it indefinitely.

Filed back in May 2020, this was the first major trial to determine whether AI companies can use copyrighted materials to train their AI models.

Legal.io Logo
Welcome to Legal.io

Connect with peers, level up skills, and find jobs at the world's best in-house legal departments

More from Legal.io

Community Perspectives: What Does it Take to Survive and Thrive as an In-House Counsel just Transitioning from Law Firms?

In-house legal professionals share their experiences finding and defining success as in-house counsel.

Community Perspectives: What Does it Take to Survive and Thrive as an In-House Counsel just Transitioning from Law Firms?
Apple To Start Accepting Competitor Wallets in the EU

To avoid a hefty fine and other penalties, Apple will allow iPhone users in the European Union to use any wallet they prefer to make payments using Apple Pay.

Apple To Start Accepting Competitor Wallets in the EU
TechnologyAntitrust and Trade Regulation
TikTok hires British Cybersecurity Firm To Allay Privacy Concerns

TikTok’s ‘Project Clover’ and ‘Project Texas’ seeks to allay privacy concerns.

TikTok hires British Cybersecurity Firm To Allay Privacy Concerns
TechnologyPrivacy
Big Law Down on Summer Associates But Increasing Partner Recruitment

Law firms are cutting back on summer associate hires, while boosting lateral partner recruitment to expand transactional services and capitalize on an economic rebound.

Big Law Down on Summer Associates But Increasing Partner Recruitment
Hiring
Lawyers Struggle To Disconnect From Work

A Bloomberg survey highlights the demanding nature of legal work, with lawyers averaging 53-hour weeks and nearly 20% billing over 80 hours in their busiest weeks.

Lawyers Struggle To Disconnect From Work
CareerMental Health
How do I properly use third-party copyrighted content in my video or stream?

Learn how to properly use third party content in your videos or stream and protect your channel against muting, takedowns, and lawsuits.

CopyrightIntellectual Property
Legal.io Newsletter - March 18 2022

Published weekly on Friday, the Legal.io Newsletter covers the latest in legal, talent & tech.

Legal.io Newsletter - March 18 2022
Legal OperationsTechnologyIn-House Counsel
FTC's Noncompete Ban: States React and IP Protections Adjust

The FTC's ban on noncompete clauses has sparked a national debate and has led to states reassessing their legal frameworks surrounding employment restrictions.

FTC's Noncompete Ban: States React and IP Protections Adjust
CareerGovernment
Legal.io Logo
Welcome to Legal.io

Connect with peers, level up your skills, and find jobs at the world's best in-house legal departments